logo

49 pages 1 hour read

Richard II

Fiction | Play | Adult | Published in 1597

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Act IVChapter Summaries & Analyses

Act IV, Scene 1 Summary

Bolingbroke and many nobles assemble for Parliament at Westminster Hall in London. Bolingbroke calls Bagot as a witness and asks him what he knows about the murder of Gloucester. Bolingbroke implies that Richard and others were responsible. Bagot accuses Aumerle of being involved in the plot against Gloucester. Aumerle denies it and says Bagot is lying. He challenges Bagot to combat, but Bolingbroke forbids Bagot to respond to the challenge.

Fitzwater then testifies that he heard Aumerle say that he was the cause of Gloucester’s death. Aumerle is defiant, saying that Fitzwater is damned for his false accusation, but Percy accuses Aumerle of lying about Fitzwater and challenges him. Another lord accuses Aumerle and challenges him. Surrey intervenes and says Fitzwater is lying and challenges him. Fitzwater, in his turn, insists that Aumerle is guilty of Gloucester’s murder; he says he himself heard Mowbray say that Aumerle sent two of his men to murder the duke at Calais. Aumerle says that Mowbray lied, and he wants to challenge him. Bolingbroke rules that the challenge must be put off until Mowbray returns, since Bolingbroke intends to repeal his banishment and restore his confiscated lands. However, Carlisle says that Mowbray has died in exile in Venice.

York enters and tells Bolingbroke that Richard is ready to renounce his crown. Bolingbroke says he will ascend the throne. Carlisle speaks up, condemning what he sees as the illegality of such a move: The king cannot be judged by those of inferior standing, especially since Richard is not even present. He accuses Bolingbroke of treason and says his actions will lead to a civil war. Northumberland responds by arresting Carlisle for treason. Bolingbroke commands that Richard be brought to the proceedings.

York enters with Richard. York tells him he has been summoned to resign his crown to Bolingbroke. Richard asks for the crown and holds it on one side while asking Bolingbroke to hold the other side. He compares himself and Bolingbroke to two buckets of water; as one is emptied, it rises up while the other one fills with water and is pulled down. They engage in a brief dialogue in which Bolingbroke says he thought Richard was willing to give up the crown and asks him if he is content to do so. Richard responds with a long, theatrical speech in which he says he will cast off all the elements of royalty until he has nothing left, other than a pit reserved for his grave. He asks in the traditional phrase for God to save Harry and grant him a peaceful reign.

After Northumberland demands that Richard read out a list of the crimes he committed against the realm, Richard demurs and says they have committed a sin in deposing a king. When Northumberland repeats the demand, Richard refers to his accusers as traitors, but then says that he is a traitor too, since he voluntarily agreed to abdicate. Richard then asks for a mirror to be brought to him so he can examine his face now that it is no longer that of a king. After some self-examination, he throws the mirror to the ground, where it smashes. He then asks Bolingbroke that one thing be granted him: that he be allowed to go. Bolingbroke instructs that Richard be sent to the Tower of London. Bolingbroke announces his coronation for the following week.

After the nobles exit, the Abbot of Westminster invites Carlisle and Aumerle to supper, where he will explain the plot that he is hatching for a rebellion.

Act IV Analysis

At the beginning of Act IV, Scene 1, the charges, countercharges, and denials regarding the murder of the Duke of Gloucester fail to establish who was responsible for the act. The chaos that ensues between the nobles, and the deep anger and mistrust that they display toward one another while debating the matter, suggest that deposing Richard has not necessarily resolved The Problem of Order and Legitimacy in the kingdom, as tensions are still running high.

It is also significant that Carlisle predicts that Bolingbroke’s seizure of power will result in civil war, which turns out to be correct. Although the Abbot of Westminster’s plot, mentioned at the end of Act IV, will soon be thwarted, a calamitous civil war will dog the reign of Henry IV, as Shakespeare will dramatize in Henry IV Part 1 and Henry IV, Part 2. Henry IV’s failure to resolve the crisis of legitimacy that begins with Richard’s overthrow reflects The Problem of Order and Legitimacy that will, the play suggests, continue to haunt England for several reigns to come.

This sense of continuing fracturing and crisis is amplified when Richard is brought forth to renounce his crown. While York initially tells Bolingbroke that Richard “with willing soul / Adopts thee heir, and his high sceptre yields / To the possession of thy royal hand” (4.1.108-10), the confrontation between the two men quickly reveals that things are not so straightforward after all. While Bolingbroke hopes that, by having Richard publicly renounce his throne he will be able to claim the throne for himself “Without suspicion” (4.1.155-57), his strategy soon backfires. In his first speech, Richard is defiant, comparing himself with Christ and proclaiming that he has been betrayed. With faux innocence, he asks, “To do what service am I sent for hither?” (4.1.176), which immediately contradicts York and Bolingbroke’s expectations that Richard has come to peacefully resign his throne.

In his speeches that follow, Richard shows himself to be the master of words as he grapples with The Crisis of Identity that is now reaching its climax. His defiant eloquence is the only way he can remain (temporarily) in control, and he makes the most of it, presenting himself as someone wronged and betrayed by those who should, by right, have served him loyally. As Richard speaks of his griefs and cares, he gives full rein to his emotions. Formally renouncing the crown, he gives up everything, including his “sacred state” (4.1.209), “pomp and majesty” (4.1.211), and his “acts, decrees, and statutes” (4.1.213).

As he acquiesces with the demands for his resignation, Richard confronts the reality that he has been transformed from a figure wielding quasi-divine authority in the realm to an ordinary subject of his rival. He calls himself “nothing” (4.1.201), complaining that not a trace of his former identity remains:

I have no name, no title;
No, not that name was given me at the font,
But ‘tis usurp’d. Alack the heavy day,
That I have worn so many winters out,
And know not now what name to call myself! (4.1.255-59).

In declaring that he “know[s] not now what name to call [him]self,” Richard summarizes the issue at the heart of his identity crisis: Without his status as king, Richard no longer knows who he is. Brought low, Richard, the formerly proud king, finds himself turning inward: He is being forced to pursue a quest for self-knowledge and self-identity, a quest that he will continue in Act V.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 49 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools