A World of Curiosities

How has the Montreal Massacre affected Gamache’s life and career? Does his behavior in the primary plot reflect any lessons he may have learned on the day of the shooting? How does the shooting connect thematically to other events in the novel, such as Fleming’s quest for revenge against Gamache?

The discovery of the painting in the hidden room is a major inciting incident in the plot. Why does the discovery of the painting provoke so much curiosity and unease? What is the significance of using a painting rather than some other type of object, especially in a community where many individuals are creative? (Clara is a famous painter, and Ruth is a well-known poet.)

John Fleming is repeatedly described as the most frightening and dangerous criminal that Gamache has ever encountered. What about Fleming and his crimes has left Gamache so disturbed? What is the impact of having the antagonist in the novel be someone with whom Gamache shares a history?

A subplot in the novel focuses on the grimoire, Anne Lamarque (a historical figure), and the history of witchcraft in Quebec and New France. What is the significance of this subplot, and how does it connect to broader themes in the novel? Do you think that Lamarque would have been welcomed into the modern-day community of Three Pines?

As the plot progresses, and the danger increases, Agent Amelia Choquet comes to play an increasingly important role in the plot. Why does Gamache trust Amelia so strongly? In what ways is Amelia like, and unlike, Gamache? How does the shared history between Amelia and Gamache (she is the daughter of the man who was responsible for the death of his parents) impact their bond and working relationship?

Part of the novel’s suspense and urgency comes from Gamache’s efforts to find out what identity Fleming has assumed. Were either of the possible suspects (Godin or Boisfranc) particularly convincing? How does Fleming manipulate perceptions of Mongeau to ensure that he deceives Gamache and the entire community of Three Pines?

Why do you think that Fiona Arsenault initially goes along with the evil plan concocted by Fleming? How does the fact that Fleming is her biological father influence her decision? Explain your response with evidence from the text.

Identify two or three examples from the novel in which a character forgives someone or admits that their initial impression was incorrect. What do these moments have in common? How do they develop the overall theme of forgiveness within the novel?